
Google recently released a HTC phone running their new open source operating system called Android. This phone has been anticipated as the iPhone’s arch-rival and something to shake up the cellular market. Apple has their totally locked down OS (operating system) and iron grasp on what goes into the iPhone. But is this G1 phone something that’s gonna make either current or potential iPhone users switch, or is it just something to satisfy a few geeks? The G1 had one of if not the biggest amount of pre-orders (over 1,000,000) in cellular market history, but it hasn’t really made itself known now that it’s been publicly released.

Don’t get me wrong the G1 has a lot going for it, but is it enough to convince the average user to pick it over the iPhone? It has some things that the iPhone lacks, such as a real full key board (something that has been one of iPhone user’s biggest complaints), turn-by-turn navigation, and most important- an open source operating system (any 3rd party application can be installed without the approval of Google or T-Mobile, and the source code can be re-written which allows one to edit the whole system). But with an open source OS comes problems, security is a HUGE risk especially for a common user who doesn’t know what not to do.
The stance that Apple takes in having a monitored OS is very legitimate, the common
everyday user will most likely screw up their phone if they are allowed to do anything and download anything. There are plenty of “rotten apples” out there that some guy in a basement wants you to download to corrupt your phone, so Apple makes their users use the App Store and iTunes to download content.
Apple’s stance in this situation makes a lot of sense, but the geeks in the world want more. Grandma may not care that she has to do everything through Apple’s store, but the more tech savvy users have voiced complaint.
Now Google has delivered what the open source, Linux loving fanatics have clamored for, but is it really going to be enough for sales?
I think it all depends on what you are looking for in the G1:
the ability to manipulate your phone to do anything and everything
a full, real keyboard
turn-by-turn navigation
Now let me clarify about the first point, I realize the iPhone can be jail-broken as well, it just isn’t like that out of the box. You can potentially make the iPhone able to download 3rd party applications and such as well, but it really damages the iPhone’s overall elegance and interface. You wouldn’t be able to install updates for your phone from Apple, etc. It takes away the iPhone’s compatibility and easiness, which gives the phone it’s elegance.
So in the end I think for the most part the iPhone is the way to go. Now I’m not and Apple fanatic by any mean, it just hits the mark. It’s amazing because it can be used and manipulated by the tech savvy, and my 65 year old uncle can use it and it makes sense to him. The UI (user interface) is top notch and it’s got all the bells and whistles. You could even jailbreak it and install 3rd party apps if you really want.
The only thing that you may want it is the real keyboard, so the G1 would be the way to go for that.

Sorry Google, you usually make great stuff, but I don’t think this phone will help you take over the world.